CIVS poll result

Poll description

Rank order the presses below in terms of the scholarly quality of their law catalogues.

Result

1. Oxford University Press (Condorcet winner: wins contests with all other choices)

2. Cambridge University Press loses to Oxford University Press by 95–56

3. Harvard University Press loses to Oxford University Press by 95–56, loses to Cambridge University Press by 93–60

4. Yale University Press loses to Oxford University Press by 117–33, loses to Harvard University Press by 113–34

5. Princeton University Press loses to Oxford University Press by 122–25, loses to Yale University Press by 70–67

6. University of Chicago Press loses to Oxford University Press by 118–28, loses to Princeton University Press by 81–51

7. Stanford University Press loses to Oxford University Press by 128–11, loses to University of Chicago Press by 88–33

8. New York University Press loses to Oxford University Press by 128–11, loses to Stanford University Press by 55–54

9. MIT Press loses to Oxford University Press by 124–11, loses to New York University Press by 63–38

10. Routledge loses to Oxford University Press by 132–7, loses to MIT Press by 57–51

11. University of Michigan Press loses to Oxford University Press by 127–7, loses to Routledge by 56–50

12. Hart Publishing loses to Oxford University Press by 125–11, loses to University of Michigan Press by 57–51

13. University of North Carolina Press loses to Oxford University Press by 129–5, loses to Hart Publishing by 57–47

14. Wiley-Blackwell loses to Oxford University Press by 129–5, loses to University of North Carolina Press by 54–40

15. Edinburgh University Press loses to Oxford University Press by 122–6, loses to Wiley-Blackwell by 49–39

16. None of the above (write-in) loses to Oxford University Press by 127–2, loses to Edinburgh University Press by 61–13

For simplicity, some details of the poll result are not shown.

Result details

	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10	11	12	13	14	15	16
1. Oxford University Press	-	95	95	117	122	118	128	128	124	132	127	125	129	129	122	127
2. Cambridge University Press	56	-	93	109	115	118	128	126	124	135	124	128	127	132	125	125
3. Harvard University Press	56	60	-	113	110	115	126	124	120	126	124	120	121	123	121	123
4. Yale University Press	33	41	34	-	70	85	103	107	106	106	110	103	111	106	110	113
5. Princeton University Press	25	31	34	67	-	81	89	94	94	96	101	93	101	104	102	105
6. University of Chicago Press	28	29	28	47	51	-	88	91	92	91	102	91	101	100	99	101
7. Stanford University Press	11	12	10	26	33	33	-	55	66	72	77	72	83	79	86	87
8. New York University Press	11	14	13	21	28	34	54	-	63	70	69	67	76	75	82	87
9. MIT Press	11	9	12	17	22	27	39	38	-	57	53	60	57	63	69	73
10. Routledge	7	4	12	26	26	35	43	43	51	-	56	60	59	78	72	84
11. University of Michigan Press	7	8	6	9	14	13	25	29	43	50	-	57	65	62	70	73
12. Hart Publishing	11	9	16	29	27	37	43	47	46	54	51	-	57	67	62	79
13. University of North Carolina Press	5	7	11	12	13	13	20	23	35	45	25	47	-	54	57	69
14. Wiley-Blackwell	5	2	9	19	10	18	25	28	32	23	34	36	40	-	49	66
15. Edinburgh University Press	6	2	4	7	7	12	12	17	18	28	22	33	29	39	-	61
16. None of the above (write-in)	2	2	4	4	4	7	11	10	14	10	13	14	14	14	13	-

Ballot report

	Cambridge University Press	Edinburgh University Press	Hart Publishing	Harvard University Press	MIT Press	New York University Press	Oxford University Press	Princeton University Press	Routledge	Stanford University Press	University of Chicago Press	University of Michigan Press	University of North Carolina Press	Wiley-Blackwell	Yale University Press	None of the above (write-in)
1.	3	No opinion	5	2	No opinion	10	1	7	6	No opinion	8	No opinion	No opinion	11	4	No opinion
2.	10	11	4	15	5	2	12	6	13	7	16	1	8	9	3	16
3.	6	16	15	3	11	10	1	2	13	9	4	12	8	14	5	7
4.	6	13	15	8	5	10	1	3	16	7	2	11	12	14	9	No opinion
5.	2	16	8	3	4	14	1	5	9	5	6	7	14	13	5	16
6.	3	15	14	1	8	10	2	5	9	12	7	16	6	13	4	16
7.	2	12	13	11	3	10	6	5	15	8	7	4	9	16	1	14
8.	2	15	14	4	3	14	1	6	14	5	8	14	14	14	7	16
9.	5	12	13	4	7	8	1	3	14	9	2	10	6	11	15	16
10.	3	16	16	1	16	16	2	4	16	16	5	16	16	16	5	16
11.	5	16	16	1	16	16	5	6	16	3	2	16	16	16	4	16
12.	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
13.	1	12	2	3	14	14	4	6	5	6	5	10	6	16	9	13
14.	1	13	12	8	7	2	5	11	14	10	4	9	6	15	3	16
15.	1	11	15	2	12	8	3	8	10	4	9	10	13	14	5	16
16.	2	No opinion	10	4	No opinion	No opinion	1	No opinion	5	6	7	8	11	9	3	No opinion
17.	3	No opinion	9	1	8	7	2	5	10	No opinion	6	No opinion	No opinion	11	4	16
18.	16	1	8	16	1	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
19.	1	16	16	16	16	5	2	4	3	16	16	16	16	16	16	6
20.	4	16	16	3	2	16	16	1	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
21.	1	16	3	4	16	16	2	16	5	16	16	16	16	6	16	7
22.	4	13	3	2	14	10	1	7	8	12	5	11	15	9	6	No opinion
23.	4	15	13	5	14	1	2	6	9	3	10	11	12	7	8	16
24.	16	16	3	15	16	16	14	1	2	14	4	16	16	6	16	16
25.	3	14	9	5	11	4	1	2	6	12	10	13	15	8	7	16
26.	2	16	16	1	16	5	3	4	16	6	5	7	16	16	8	16
27.	2	6	15	4	11	13	1	3	11	8	14	11	11	5	7	16
28.	1	16	8	3	16	7	2	6	16	16	4	16	16	16	4	16
29.	5	11	14	1	3	8	7	2	13	10	6	9	15	12	4	16
30.	1	13	4	2	9	7	6	4	14	8	10	11	12	15	3	16
31.	6	16	7	2	16	16	4	3	9	16	5	16	16	16	1	8
32.	2	No opinion	No opinion	1	No opinion	No opinion	3	4	No opinion	6	7	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	5	No opinion
33.	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	16	9	11	12	13	14	15	10
34.	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	2	5	No opinion	3	No opinion	No opinion	4	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	1
35.	5	12	13	1	11	7	15	6	11	3	4	11	11	14	2	16
36.	16	16	16	16	16	16	1	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
37.	5	11	16	2	7	9	1	3	10	4	12	15	14	13	6	8
38.	1	No opinion	No opinion	6	5	7	2	10	9	3	8	11	12	No opinion	4	16
39.	5	16	14	3	12	8	4	1	9	13	2	15	7	11	6	10
40.	5	No opinion	No opinion	2	8	3	1	6	7	10	9	11	12	No opinion	4	16
41.	1	No opinion	No opinion	3	No opinion	No opinion	2	7	No opinion	6	No opinion	No opinion	8	5	4	16
42.	2	16	7	5	16	16	1	16	3	16	8	16	16	4	6	16
43.	2	16	16	4	10	3	1	6	16	5	8	9	11	16	6	16
44.	2	15	4	3	12	10	1	8	7	13	9	11	14	16	4	16
45.	1	15	9	3	6	9	2	4	13	8	5	11	12	14	7	16
46.	1	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
47.	4	14	15	1	11	6	3	8	9	7	5	13	16	10	2	12
48.	4	No opinion	No opinion	2	No opinion	No opinion	1	6	No opinion	5	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	3	No opinion
49.	1	16	16	2	16	16	3	16	16	16	5	16	16	16	4	16
50.	1	16	7	6	10	9	5	3	11	8	4	12	16	13	2	16
51.	6	11	14	7	10	3	8	4	13	2	16	15	9	12	1	5
52.	16	16	16	1	16	16	2	16	16	16	16	16	3	16	16	16
53.	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
54.	1	15	6	3	7	9	2	8	11	5	10	12	13	14	4	16
55.	7	16	16	1	10	5	3	16	16	9	2	6	8	16	4	16
56.	2	16	5	3	16	16	1	16	4	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
57.	1	14	5	4	15	10	2	3	6	12	9	11	13	7	8	16
58.	1	13	8	5	6	9	3	7	11	10	2	14	12	15	4	16
59.	2	14	12	3	10	8	1	6	13	7	4	9	11	15	4	No opinion
60.	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
61.	5	10	13	6	1	8	4	2	14	9	3	11	12	15	7	16
62.	4	13	11	2	8	6	1	5	14	9	7	10	12	15	3	16
63.	2	No opinion	No opinion	3	No opinion	No opinion	1	6	No opinion	No opinion	5	No opinion	7	No opinion	4	No opinion
64.	4	12	11	2	5	10	1	7	13	9	6	8	15	14	3	16
65.	1	16	6	3	16	16	2	4	16	16	5	16	16	16	5	16
66.	6	14	15	7	9	5	10	2	13	8	1	4	12	11	3	16
67.	6	11	16	9	4	3	1	2	13	10	12	15	7	13	5	16
68.	1	14	12	3	8	9	2	6	11	4	7	10	13	15	5	16
69.	16	16	16	2	16	16	1	3	16	16	4	16	16	16	16	16
70.	2	16	3	12	13	15	1	5	4	16	10	11	16	6	9	16
71.	16	16	16	1	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
72.	2	16	3	16	16	16	1	5	16	16	16	16	16	16	4	16
73.	2	16	16	3	16	16	1	5	16	3	6	16	16	16	4	16
74.	4	12	12	3	12	10	1	7	12	8	11	5	9	6	2	12
75.	4	16	8	6	16	11	1	2	7	12	5	9	10	16	3	16
76.	3	16	1	16	16	16	2	16	16	16	4	16	5	16	16	16
77.	4	5	11	6	7	8	1	9	10	14	10	3	15	14	13	2
78.	5	13	14	6	10	9	4	7	1	3	8	11	12	15	1	16
79.	1	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
80.	3	16	16	4	16	7	5	16	16	6	1	8	9	16	2	16
81.	2	16	4	3	16	16	1	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
82.	2	15	14	5	13	10	1	7	6	12	3	11	4	8	9	16
83.	5	12	13	2	11	7	3	8	15	6	1	9	10	14	4	16
84.	2	11	13	4	9	14	1	3	8	15	5	12	10	6	7	16
85.	3	No opinion	9	1	No opinion	4	2	6	5	No opinion	7	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	8	No opinion
86.	2	9	7	3	16	8	1	4	5	16	16	16	16	6	16	16
87.	1	12	6	2	11	13	3	7	5	10	4	13	15	8	9	16
88.	2	12	6	3	11	11	1	5	14	11	7	11	13	16	4	16
89.	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	15	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
90.	2	14	11	3	10	12	1	4	13	7	6	8	15	9	5	16
91.	1	16	16	4	6	10	1	5	12	9	3	16	16	8	7	No opinion
92.	1	15	7	2	16	5	3	11	12	10	6	9	8	14	4	16
93.	3	9	16	2	10	8	6	7	11	12	4	15	14	13	1	16
94.	3	16	16	1	16	16	2	16	16	5	16	6	16	16	4	16
95.	3	No opinion	No opinion	2	No opinion	16	1	4	No opinion	No opinion	6	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	5	16
96.	4	No opinion	16	1	8	5	2	7	10	9	3	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	6	16
97.	2	15	3	6	14	9	1	10	4	11	9	12	13	5	7	16
98.	3	15	14	1	7	8	4	2	13	9	5	10	11	12	6	16
99.	1	16	16	4	16	16	3	16	16	16	2	16	16	16	5	16
100.	1	16	16	3	16	16	16	4	16	5	2	16	16	16	16	16
101.	1	16	16	2	16	16	16	16	16	16	3	5	16	16	4	16
102.	2	16	6	5	8	7	4	9	16	16	16	16	16	16	1	16
103.	2	16	1	16	16	16	3	16	4	16	16	16	16	5	16	16
104.	1	16	9	4	16	16	6	2	16	7	6	16	16	16	3	16
105.	3	14	15	2	6	12	1	4	9	8	7	10	13	11	5	16
106.	3	13	11	5	9	15	4	6	12	7	2	10	14	8	1	16
107.	1	9	9	4	16	16	5	2	16	7	6	10	16	16	3	16
108.	2	10	11	4	12	14	13	3	8	15	1	5	7	9	6	16
109.	1	16	8	2	10	14	3	4	12	6	16	13	16	11	5	16
110.	2	6	16	3	15	15	1	5	15	15	15	15	15	15	4	15
111.	3	14	8	1	13	2	4	12	10	5	9	11	6	15	7	16
112.	3	13	14	1	9	8	4	7	12	10	5	6	11	15	2	16
113.	3	16	16	5	16	16	2	1	6	16	6	16	16	16	4	16
114.	6	8	12	3	16	9	2	5	13	7	1	10	11	16	4	No opinion
115.	4	No opinion	No opinion	1	No opinion	No opinion	2	3	No opinion	7	6	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	5	No opinion
116.	2	16	16	3	16	5	1	16	6	16	16	16	16	16	4	16
117.	4	12	16	2	9	14	1	13	7	5	10	3	8	11	6	15
118.	6	16	16	3	12	5	4	1	16	10	7	8	9	16	2	8
119.	2	14	6	3	13	11	1	4	5	10	8	12	15	9	7	16
120.	1	12	14	5	9	7	2	10	13	8	6	11	4	15	3	16
121.	5	15	8	2	14	12	3	1	13	9	6	11	16	10	4	7
122.	1	16	16	3	16	16	2	16	16	16	5	16	16	16	4	16
123.	2	16	16	3	16	9	1	4	8	8	6	7	16	10	5	11
124.	2	No opinion	No opinion	3	No opinion	7	1	5	No opinion	7	4	7	No opinion	No opinion	6	No opinion
125.	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	1	16
126.	2	No opinion	5	3	No opinion	No opinion	1	No opinion	4	No opinion	6	No opinion	No opinion	7	7	No opinion
127.	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
128.	1	4	4	4	4	4	4	5	3	4	5	5	5	2	5	16
129.	1	16	3	4	16	16	2	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
130.	3	No opinion	4	1	No opinion	No opinion	2	5	No opinion	No opinion	7	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	6	No opinion
131.	2	16	16	16	4	16	1	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	3	16
132.	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	1	16
133.	4	14	15	2	11	3	8	5	13	6	9	10	12	16	1	No opinion
134.	5	5	16	1	16	16	2	16	6	7	3	16	16	16	4	8
135.	5	15	6	8	14	12	1	2	10	11	3	13	4	7	9	16
136.	3	6	2	4	No opinion	7	1	No opinion	4	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	8	No opinion	16
137.	4	11	12	1	3	8	2	6	16	10	7	13	14	9	5	16
138.	14	11	13	9	3	4	12	8	2	5	1	6	7	15	10	16
139.	3	No opinion	No opinion	1	No opinion	10	2	5	No opinion	9	7	No opinion	No opinion	No opinion	4	8
140.	16	16	16	1	16	16	5	16	16	2	4	16	16	16	3	16
141.	5	16	16	1	8	4	3	6	16	5	2	9	10	16	7	16
142.	3	16	16	6	8	10	2	4	7	9	1	16	16	16	5	16
143.	9	16	16	1	12	6	2	5	10	11	3	8	7	16	4	16
144.	2	16	16	1	16	16	4	6	16	16	5	16	16	16	3	16
145.	1	16	2	5	16	11	3	6	6	8	10	9	16	4	7	16
146.	2	16	16	3	16	6	1	4	7	16	16	16	16	16	5	16
147.	6	16	16	3	16	8	2	4	9	10	5	7	11	16	1	16
148.	2	No opinion	No opinion	4	No opinion	8	1	3	No opinion	7	5	No opinion	9	No opinion	6	No opinion
149.	1	No opinion	No opinion	2	7	6	4	5	6	4	3	6	5	No opinion	6	No opinion
150.	6	13	14	1	9	7	5	2	11	8	4	10	15	12	3	16
151.	1	16	16	16	16	16	2	16	3	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
152.	2	No opinion	11	3	7	12	1	4	10	8	5	9	No opinion	13	6	No opinion
153.	1	16	16	3	16	16	2	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	16
154.	7	16	13	9	10	8	5	1	12	11	2	15	6	14	3	No opinion
155.	2	7	4	6	14	9	1	11	12	8	3	15	10	13	5	16
156.	3	10	9	2	16	8	1	7	6	11	15	12	14	13	4	5
157.	3	16	2	1	7	5	1	10	8	4	9	16	16	16	11	16
158.	2	16	7	3	16	16	1	6	4	16	16	16	16	5	16	16
159.	2	13	12	5	11	9	1	3	14	4	10	6	7	16	8	16
160.	3	15	5	2	9	10	1	4	12	8	7	11	12	14	6	16
161.	7	9	14	3	10	11	5	6	12	4	1	13	8	15	2	16
162.	8	15	14	4	13	10	2	3	12	5	9	7	1	11	6	16
163.	16	16	16	4	16	1	2	16	16	16	16	16	16	16	4	16

Ballots are shown in a randomly generated order.

[Download ballots in CSV format]

Rank 1:
Oxford University Press (6): vs. 0 : (56 - 95) vs. 3 : (56 - 95) vs. 14 : (33 - 117) vs. 10 : (28 - 118) vs. 7 : (25 - 122) vs. 4 : (11 - 124) vs. 2 : (11 - 125) vs. 1 : (6 - 122) vs. 5 : (11 - 128) vs. 9 : (11 - 128) vs. 11 : (7 - 127) vs. 12 : (5 - 129) vs. 13 : (5 - 129) vs. 15 : (2 - 127) vs. 8 : (7 - 132)
Rank 2:
Cambridge University Press (0): vs. 3 : (60 - 93) vs. 14 : (41 - 109) vs. 7 : (31 - 115) vs. 10 : (29 - 118) vs. 5 : (14 - 126) vs. 4 : (9 - 124) vs. 11 : (8 - 124) vs. 9 : (12 - 128) vs. 2 : (9 - 128) vs. 12 : (7 - 127) vs. 1 : (2 - 125) vs. 15 : (2 - 125) vs. 13 : (2 - 132) vs. 8 : (4 - 135)
Rank 3:
Harvard University Press (3): vs. 7 : (34 - 110) vs. 14 : (34 - 113) vs. 10 : (28 - 115) vs. 2 : (16 - 120) vs. 4 : (12 - 120) vs. 12 : (11 - 121) vs. 5 : (13 - 124) vs. 13 : (9 - 123) vs. 8 : (12 - 126) vs. 9 : (10 - 126) vs. 1 : (4 - 121) vs. 11 : (6 - 124) vs. 15 : (4 - 123)
Rank 4:
Yale University Press (14): vs. 7 : (67 - 70) vs. 10 : (47 - 85) vs. 2 : (29 - 103) vs. 9 : (26 - 103) vs. 8 : (26 - 106) vs. 5 : (21 - 107) vs. 13 : (19 - 106) vs. 4 : (17 - 106) vs. 12 : (12 - 111) vs. 11 : (9 - 110) vs. 1 : (7 - 110) vs. 15 : (4 - 113)
Rank 5:
Princeton University Press (7): vs. 10 : (51 - 81) vs. 9 : (33 - 89) vs. 2 : (27 - 93) vs. 5 : (28 - 94) vs. 8 : (26 - 96) vs. 4 : (22 - 94) vs. 11 : (14 - 101) vs. 12 : (13 - 101) vs. 13 : (10 - 104) vs. 1 : (7 - 102) vs. 15 : (4 - 105)
Rank 6:
University of Chicago Press (10): vs. 2 : (37 - 91) vs. 9 : (33 - 88) vs. 8 : (35 - 91) vs. 5 : (34 - 91) vs. 4 : (27 - 92) vs. 13 : (18 - 100) vs. 1 : (12 - 99) vs. 12 : (13 - 101) vs. 11 : (13 - 102) vs. 15 : (7 - 101)
Rank 7:
Stanford University Press (9): vs. 5 : (54 - 55) vs. 4 : (39 - 66) vs. 2 : (43 - 72) vs. 8 : (43 - 72) vs. 11 : (25 - 77) vs. 13 : (25 - 79) vs. 12 : (20 - 83) vs. 1 : (12 - 86) vs. 15 : (11 - 87)
Rank 8:
New York University Press (5): vs. 2 : (47 - 67) vs. 4 : (38 - 63) vs. 8 : (43 - 70) vs. 11 : (29 - 69) vs. 13 : (28 - 75) vs. 12 : (23 - 76) vs. 1 : (17 - 82) vs. 15 : (10 - 87)
Rank 9:
MIT Press (4): vs. 8 : (51 - 57) vs. 11 : (43 - 53) vs. 2 : (46 - 60) vs. 12 : (35 - 57) vs. 13 : (32 - 63) vs. 1 : (18 - 69) vs. 15 : (14 - 73)
Rank 10:
Routledge (8): vs. 11 : (50 - 56) vs. 2 : (54 - 60) vs. 12 : (45 - 59) vs. 1 : (28 - 72) vs. 13 : (23 - 78) vs. 15 : (10 - 84)
Rank 11:
University of Michigan Press (11): vs. 2 : (51 - 57) vs. 13 : (34 - 62) vs. 12 : (25 - 65) vs. 1 : (22 - 70) vs. 15 : (13 - 73)
Rank 12:
Hart Publishing (2): vs. 12 : (47 - 57) vs. 1 : (33 - 62) vs. 13 : (36 - 67) vs. 15 : (14 - 79)
Rank 13:
University of North Carolina Press (12): vs. 13 : (40 - 54) vs. 1 : (29 - 57) vs. 15 : (14 - 69)
Rank 14:
Wiley-Blackwell (13): vs. 1 : (39 - 49) vs. 15 : (14 - 66)
Rank 15:
Edinburgh University Press (1): vs. 15 : (13 - 61)
Rank 16:
None of the above (write-in) (15): vs. 1 : (61 - 13)

Feel like voting on something else? Try one of these public polls:

Condorcet Internet Voting Service

Poll Results: Which press publishes the best scholarly monographs in law?

Poll description

Result

Result details

Ballot report

Condorcet Internet Voting Service

Poll Results: Which press publishes the best scholarly monographs in law?

Poll description

Result

Result detailsHide details

Ballot report

Result details